History of Chambers of Commerce
This research by Professor Robert Bennett aims to give definitive historical analysis of chambers of commerce and other local business associations. It links with projects on the historical role of business associations and how the geography of membership of associations has adapted over time related to economic evolution. This develops the role of 'associational governance' as a means, between state and market, to involve businesses, not-for-profit organisations, and public agents more effectively in policy exchanges to overcome information asymmetry to develop more effective policy supports.
There are business associations and chambers of commerce in all countries of the world. They fall into two types: those governed by public law (as in much of continental Europe), and those governed by private law as voluntary organisations. Although the earliest private law chamber was in France at Marseilles, founded in 1599, this was incorporated into the French public law system in 1779.
The main recent outputs from this stream has been on the system of private law chambers that began in cities across the Atlantic economy from the 1760s and 1770s. The earliest were in New York, Jersey, Guernsey, Liverpool, Manchester, Charleston, Boston, Jamaica, Quebec, Nova Scotia, Dublin, Belfast, Glasgow and other port cities in the UK and Ireland. Their origin was related to the protests that led to the American Revolution, and arose from anger with: government policies, business taxes, inadequate trade treaties, odious government officials, and other government 'bads' especially the war with America. From this origin private law chambers then diffused to cover most cities, towns and smaller places.
This topic interrelates with research on services to SMEs and public policy.
These developments are covered in the following books, and a series of papers:
Bennett, R. J. (ed.) (2017) The Documents of the first Chambers of Commerce in Britain and Ireland, 1767-1839, British Academy and Oxford University Press, Records of Social and Economic History.
Bennett, R. J. (2011) Local Business Voice: The history of Chambers of Commerce in Britain, Ireland and Revolutionary America, 1760-2011, Oxford University Press. [USA weblink]
Read practitioner reviews at:
- Chamber Executive (Spring 2012), Magazine of the Association of American Chamber of Commerce Executives (ACCE)
- London Business Matters (March 2012), Magazine of the London Chamber of Commerce
Read academic reviews at:
One of the earliest chambers showing the blending of anger with new modes of lobbying government was Liverpool, 1774-1796.
Bennett, R. J. (2010) The Voice of Liverpool Business: The first chamber of commerce and the Atlantic economy, 1774-c.1796, Liverpool Chamber of Commerce; 172pp.
Read reviews at:
Chamber of commerce history
A report of the seminar [PDF] is available.
The Chair's remarks (Sir Peter Hall, UCL) are at the beginning (point 0.00), end, and in between each presentation. The presentations run as follows:
- 2.00 - 25.00 - Bob Bennett (Cambridge University)
- 27.38 - 40.00 - Martin Daunton (Cambridge University)
- 42.00 – 51.00 - Wyn Grant (Warwick University)
- 52.46 – 1.09.00 - Martyn Pellew (President, BCC)
- 1.12.01 - 1.24.36 - Andrew Lansley MP (Former BCC Deputy Director General) [Transcript of Andrew Lansley's remarks]
A presentation 'Webinar' to US audiences through the US Association of Chamber of Commerce Chief Executives (ACCE) on 7 March 2012 based on 'Local Business Voice':
More about chamber of commerce history:
- A database of chamber of commerce financial and other benchmarking information 1790-2005
- Commentaries about the archives of the UK national chambers association BCC/ABCC (which includes Ireland, 1860-1922) and the London chamber of commerce
- The members of the earliest chambers: listings and networks for each chamber
- The NCT, chambers of trade and small town chambers 1897-2007
- Interlocks of early chambers and banks 1767-1823: doi:10.1080/00076791.2012.725163 [Download data table]
- A complete record of the main records of early chambers is contained in Documents of the first Chambers of Commerce in Britain and Ireland, 1767-1839, British Academy and Oxford University Press, Records of Social and Economic History. Available late 2017
The modern chamber of commerce: Modern private law chambers are leading voluntary organizations for their localities and often act as partners with government in regional and local economic initiatives. They are democratically elected from the business community, have transparent governance that offers legitimacy, and are locally-rooted. They offer advantages over ad hoc and government-appointed bodies that often carry no weight with businesses and usually cost a lot to maintain.
Read some recent commentary and blogs at:
- How anger underpinned the early chambers, Harvard Business Review blog, October 2011
- 'Georgian Liverpool's battle for the Big Society', History Today, June 2011, pp. 4-6.
- Public and private law chambers of commerce: past and future, 'Regions', Quarterly Magazine of the Regional Studies Association, No. 284, Winter 2011, pp. 23-5.
- Modern chambers of commerce need more fire in the belly in their relationships with government, British Politics and Policy at LSE.
Using chambers as partners allows governments to draw on networks of traded and un-traded dependencies between businesses, offering business commitment, a means for engagement, and helping dissemination of information. As existing networks chambers are low cost: they have no set-up costs and are self-maintaining. They cover 'natural' areas meshing closely with local geographical clusters. Associations are also usually far more effective than government-led policy interventions with SMEs, contributing to 'hard' bottom-line benefits, as well as 'soft' management skills.
Read more on chamber services to SMEs and public policy.
Other main publications:
- Bennett, R. J. (2015) Management adaptation of business association services: Long-term stability 1783-2012 and 'change points' for Irish Chambers of Commerce, forthcoming, Irish Journal of Management.
- Bennett, R. J. (2015) Collective action when needed: The Kingston chamber of commerce in Jamaica, 1778-85, The Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History. doi:10.1080/03086534.2014.974877
- Bennett, R. J. (2014) Searching for new models of business representation: the Liverpool Committee or Board of Trade, 1775–1794, Northern History, 51, 2, 263-89 doi:10.1179/0078172X14Z.00000000065
- Bennett, R. J. (2014) Alignments, interests and tensions over 'Reform' in 18th Century Britain: The Manchester Committee of Trade 1774-86, Northern History, 51, 1, 61-90. doi:10.1179/0078172X13Z.00000000061
- Bennett, R. J. (2013) Network interlocks: The connected emergence of chambers of commerce and provincial banks in the British Isles, 1767–1823, Business History, 55, 8, 1288-1317. doi:10.1080/00076791.2012.725163 [Download data table] Bennett, R. J. and Robson, P.J.A. (2004) The role of trust and contract in the supply of business advice, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 28, 471-488.
- Bratton, W., Bennett, R.J. and P.J.A. Robson, (2003) Critical mass and economies of scale in the supply of services by business support organisations, Journal of Services Marketing, 17(7), 730-752.
- Bennett, R.J. (1999) 'Explaining the membership of sectoral business associations.' Environment and Planning A 31: 877-898.
- Bennett, R.J. and Robson, P.J.A. (1999) 'Intensity of interaction in supply of business advice and client impact: a comparison of consultancy, business associations and government support initiatives for SMEs.' British Journal of Management: 10: 351-369 [another version as working paper 142 Cambridge: ESRC Centre for Business Research, 47pp]
- Bennett, R.J. (1997) 'The relations between government and business associations in Britain: an evaluation of recent developments. Policy Studies 18: 5-33.
- Bennett, R.J. (ed). (1996) Trade Associations in Britain and Germany and the Single European Market (Anglo-German Foundation, London and Bonn)
- Bennett, R.J., Krebs, G. and Zimmermann, H (1993) Chambers of Commerce in Britain and Germany (Anglo-German Foundation, London and Bonn)